Did Freud think of himself as a scientist? Did he think of psychoanalysis as science? Absolutely. uh uh there's no questionabout it that uh Freud self-concept was that he was doing science. Uh his
the gains not only are maintained but the patient continues to improve. In other words, if you'll excuse the bad psychoanalysis you don't always need to take a hammer to crack a nut you know but psychoanalytical therapies designed
And so I started devouring literature on the subject-- neuroscience, evolutionary biology, psychology, psychoanalysis . And in the course of this research, I came upon three kind of discoveries that were very fundamental, that sort of groundedthe book that came out of that.
It is relevant to understanding how our psychological makeup and our identity and personality developed. And psychoanalysis is useful for people for self-exploration, or for finding out how you can avoid certain conflicts that may occur in your life-- whether it's you don't get along with your boss or you have no gratifying romantic relationships or you're engaging in self-defeating behavior,
Freud's was the first talk therapy and there the the one that uh is so often contrasted with psychoanalysis namely CBT cognitive behavioral therapy people don't seem to realize Aaron Beck uh the inventor of CBT was a psychoanalyst you
Yeah, because you're always-- for me, I've always been reinventing, from the moment I was a young child. I've done psychoanalysis . But I think sometimes we think that the only answer is therapy.
It could be in terms of values. It could be in terms of education or other things like that. And so learning about transference--I'm not suggesting that everybody be on the couch and do psychoanalysis for 15 years-- but still reflecting on those things about how you're caring about credit and blame, how your identity is wrapped up in what you're doing for better or for worse, can be very important.
People with Parkinsonian, indeed, begin to walk like robots. one of the great triumphs of psychoanalysis or one of the great catastrophes.
And my shrink never spoke. You have to understand how psychoanalysis works, is that you're doing the heavy lifting. You go in there, and you say whatever comes into your head.
This is a network graph, an intellectual network graph of relationships between Viennese psychiatrists and psychoanalysis . Vienna really was the cradle of psychoanalysis at this time. And so you can see that people with big letters are the real nodes in this connection.
He lived in-- you know-- in New York. And at a time when psychoanalysis was in vogue. And I wonder if given the periodic depressions that he went through and this self-depreciation that he
If they get it as right as the Korean BBQ on the corner that get it right. I know he despises all the psychoanalysis in the film, and his friends psychoanalyzing. I mean, just from my perspective-- and he's going to laugh at this, I'm sure-- but I think there's a memory that from very early on when
And so you can see that people with big letters are the real nodes in this connection. And here you have the liberal Jewish psychoanalysists, whose names you would know-- Anna Freud, Sigmund Freud, and their associates. And then you have Asperger, the young man pictured there, and Hamburger, who are really off on the periphery of mainstream psychoanalysis .
At the time, he was at Columbia. And Robert Spitzer's story is that he hated Freudian psychoanalysis , because his mother was miserable her whole life, and she died unhappy, and she'd gone to Freudian analyst after Freudian analyst and none of them helped her.
countenance we believe that clouds are for dreamers and their contemplation benefits the S indeed all who consider the shapes they see in them will save money on psychoanalysis bills and so we say to all who listen look up Marvel at the ephemeral Beauty and always remember to live life with
Yeah, and so for what people have told-- I certainly can't speak for experience of what it's like to be a woman, but I've done a lot of research It's something that a psychoanalyst once said to me when I was in psychoanalysis .
was prone to, why he never considered going into something that everybody seemed to be doing at that time? Oh, I think a really long psychoanalysis would have done him a lot of good. And oh, the lucky analyst.
like, human conversation." My whole point is not that at all. It's that of course at the right side of the spectrum it doesn't look like engineering anymore, right? It looks like friendship and love and psychoanalysis and all these other tools that we have. But here's what I want to do. I want to be very specific to my colleagues in regenerative medicine and everything. Just imagine if I, you know, if I went to a bioengineering department or a genetics department and I started
specific to my colleagues in regenerative medicine and everything. Just imagine if I, you know, if I went to a bioengineering department or a genetics department and I started talking about high-level, you know, cognition and psychoanalysis , right? They don't want to hear that. So I focus on the engineering approach... Because I want to say, look, this is not a philosophical problem. This is not a linguistics problem. We are not trying to define
shopify.com/vox. That'sify.com/vox. Let's talk about therapy. Freud said in 1938 that psychoanalysis was imperfect, but it was the best therapeutic technique we had. How far have we come since then? I know psychoanalysis isn't
don't seem to realize Aaron Beck uh the inventor of CBT was a psychoanalyst you know it's it's it's literally directly in the person of Aaron Beck derived from psychoanalysis . So uh when I say that talking therapy remains the most effective therapy uh it's not an opinion. I mean this is if
You can see these thin lines. This is a network graph, an intellectual network graph of relationships between Viennese psychiatrists and psychoanalysis . Vienna really was the cradle of psychoanalysis at this time.
There was a sense somehow we can get out of all this through solidarity, through working together. There was an educated community and people who had never gone-- couple of years of elementary school discussing the latest varieties of Freudian psychoanalysis , the last concert of the Budapest string quartet and so on.
Or is that-- because like psychotherapy, for example, or psychoanalysis , would suggest that there is some underlying cause for that anxiety.
to correct for those errors and biases. Understand your own story. So again, you don't have to do 15 years of psychoanalysis , but knowing your story and what motivates you, and what's your identity and how is that related to work and how you come across and how you're credited and blamed. And how does that propel your success, but also, how does that hold you back? So what is your story and what are other people's
Remember this is the era of Sigmund Freud, so people start doing psychoanalysis , see your shrink, and so on. Women start to smoke in the 1920's.
something, right? What kind of tools are you going to use? And this is a major part of my framework, is that all of these kinds of things are operational claims. Are you going to use the tools of hardware rewiring, of control theory and cybernetics, of behavior science, of psychoanalysis and love and friendship? Like, what are the interaction protocols that you bring, right? And then in first-person, it's this notion of having an inner perspective and being a system that has valence and cares about the
most important mystery for all of us to both on the science and also on the personal level. So that's what I'm interested in. - So your work is focused on starting at the physics, going all the way to friendship and love and psychoanalysis . - Yeah, although, actually I would turn that upside down. I think that pyramid is backwards, and I think it's behavior science at the bottom. I think it's behavior science all the
- You could try. - to try and then see. That's the underpinnings of the criticism of anthropomorphization, because, what is that? That's like psychoanalysis of another human could technically be applied to robots, to AI systems, to more primitive biological systems, and so on. Try.
Let's talk about therapy. Freud said in 1938 that psychoanalysis was imperfect, but it was the best therapeutic technique we had. How far have we come since then? I know psychoanalysis isn't the only form of talk therapy. I mean, what would you say is the best
People with Parkinsonian, indeed, begin to walk like robots. By the way, a partial answer to your question, he was in psychoanalysis for 50 years two to three times a week with the same person, which is either
They had collaborated on the Declaration of Independence, and Adams went up to Braintree, Massachusetts And he said, because it's no more possible to discuss the beginnings or the history of psychoanalysis and not start with Freud.
And here you have the liberal Jewish psychoanalysists, whose names you would know-- Anna Freud, Sigmund Freud, and their associates. And then you have Asperger, the young man pictured there, and Hamburger, who are really off on the periphery of mainstream psychoanalysis . And they were considered kind of crackpots by the people whose names we would most respect today.
I set out to shoot a film that explored his early childhood, Chez Panisse, and Stars, and it was really going to be bookended by Mexico. Well, it was like a big ocean liner, speaking of psychoanalysis .
And the change has been extraordinary to the point that now we have effective treatments for most things. Why? Because her husband, who had manic depressive illness, was treated with psychoanalysis , never given lithium, and committed suicide.
There were a number of orphans from the war, and just thousands of children destitute and in need of help. So you have a very progressive welfare system that gets developed in Vienna to help these children, including leading psychoanalysists and psychiatrists who get involved.
contrasted with psychoanalysis namely CBT cognitive behavioral therapy people don't seem to realize Aaron Beck uh the inventor of CBT was a psychoanalyst you know it's it's it's literally directly in the person of Aaron Beck derived from psychoanalysis .